BoutCheetah

Rules

• You may only vote ONCE.
• You may not change your vote.
• You may not vote for your own work.
• You must post one valid reason along with your vote, otherwise it will not be counted.
• You may not reveal who made a signature.

---

Entries


#1
(http://i1095.photobucket.com/albums/i477/bcsotw/SOTW%2011%20-%20Marvel/sotw11pig.png)

#2
(http://i1095.photobucket.com/albums/i477/bcsotw/SOTW%2011%20-%20Marvel/carnage_sig_final.png)

#3
(http://i1095.photobucket.com/albums/i477/bcsotw/SOTW%2011%20-%20Marvel/1z20efa.png)

#4
(http://i1095.photobucket.com/albums/i477/bcsotw/SOTW%2011%20-%20Marvel/e3RLP.png)

#5
(http://i1095.photobucket.com/albums/i477/bcsotw/SOTW%2011%20-%20Marvel/ghostrider.png)

#6
(http://i1095.photobucket.com/albums/i477/bcsotw/SOTW%2011%20-%20Marvel/33wo9pc.jpg)

Entries this week were weak. Dunno if I'd even consider #1 a GFX sig..

2 is ok but the concept is bad. I don't understand it at all and I don't really want to.
3..too lq for my liking.
4 has bad blending and is overly sharpened.
5 would be great, but the text makes it weird. I don't like the text. Didn't even spell Ghost right.
6 looks like something dii would do. A bit too pixelly but the best of these six by far.

I'd like to see better next week. You were given two weeks for this, and they were all inadequate. ;\

Not gonna lie, this week was a bit of a disappointment for myself, as well.

voting for 5

even though gHOst is spelled wrong, still the best one up there

ew @ 1
2 looks too simple and boring
3 looks unoriginal (y u no use cooler render)
4 looks decent
5 is decent
6 is messy

between 4 and 5 i'll go with 4 because pig said 5.

Quote from: Allie on March 17, 2012, 01:01:20 AM
Entries this week were weak.

Voting for 1 Its awesome :) My dream poster

None...

^then y post???

I'm struggling to see the difference between #5 and Ghost Rider 29. =\  I guess it's the text C4D on top.

#1 and 6.

idc 1's even a sig or not, it looks good.

Quote from: Nefarious on March 17, 2012, 02:27:33 AM
I'm struggling to see the difference between #5 and Ghost Rider 29. =\  I guess it's the text C4D on top.

(click to show/hide)

https://marvel.com/comic_books/issue/22493/ghost_rider_2006_29

A few effects were added. Ike actually won a few SOTW's ago by barely adding anything to a stock.

#5 because its the only one that looks good in my eyes

#6, best one up there. Very thematic, good work with text, etc. This one is actually pretty good, not compared to any of the other crappy ones too. =]

#5

Quote from: Allie on March 17, 2012, 01:01:20 AM
Entries this week were weak

#5 cause it looks best.

Quote from: Nefarious on March 17, 2012, 02:27:33 AM
I'm struggling to see the difference between #5 and Ghost Rider 29. =\  I guess it's the text C4D on top.

(click to show/hide)

https://marvel.com/comic_books/issue/22493/ghost_rider_2006_29

I agree, even though I vote #5 as it's pretty much the best one out there.

#5

and...

Quote from: iwasbobo on March 17, 2012, 01:17:12 AM
Not gonna lie, this week was a bit of a disappointment for myself, as well.

They all suck.

i'd say #5 looks the best even with the mispelt ghost but

Quote from: Allie on March 17, 2012, 01:01:20 AM
Entries this week were weak

3 loooks like a real comic and it all so grundy and it comingout of sig

All of them are bad. I vote #5 though, but I agree with Allie, you had 2 weeks and none of them are good. Even ghost is spelt wrong...

I'm not a fan of this theme, but I will go with #4. Seems to be the best one in my opinion.
Lol@Gohst.

whoever made #5 sux u spelled it wrong g2hell

i vote 2 cuz it looks ight

Quote from: Allie on March 17, 2012, 01:01:20 AM
Entries this week were weak. Dunno if I'd even consider #1 a GFX sig..

2 is ok but the concept is bad. I don't understand it at all and I don't really want to.
3..too lq for my liking.
4 has bad blending and is overly sharpened.
5 would be great, but the text makes it weird. I don't like the text. Didn't even spell Ghost right.
6 looks like something dii would do. A bit too pixelly but the best of these six by far.

I'd like to see better next week. You were given two weeks for this, and they were all inadequate. ;\

Lol I didn't even enter xD.. And  not to be rude or something but if I did something like that I wouldn't have even sent it..  :-\

anyway those are really poor.. I can't even vote.. so I guess #4 because it is a little decent? xD

Number 5..
Um..... It doesn't look that bad compared to the other signatures up there. 

im very surpriused w/all of you #5 is blitzed by #6 and #2 o_O!

^ This. Can't believe it's getting that many votes. xD

I like #3 the most. Making it pop out is kewl.

Lol I probably should have entered. Sadly I didn't even finish my entry. :(

(http://i.imgur.com/XSkc7.png)

Quote from: Ike86 on March 18, 2012, 01:44:35 PM
Lol I probably should have entered. Sadly I didn't even finish my entry. :(

(http://i.imgur.com/XSkc7.png)

That would've won regardless if you finished or not. lol

lol nuc no

too empty on the left side

#2 for the effects.

I vote Ike's.

honestly i dont like most of the entries
even mine sucks ( i made it for lolz anyway)
i vote for 2 i like the depth and the focus of the sig

wolverine ones are good too but idk 2 just seems to look better overall