no it's not.. idk why they are saying that lol.. i mean it's good, it's not below average and i'm not being a **** btw. it's nice and u did more than most people on their first sigs so das cool. text effects were a nice thought but simplicity really works best for sigs imo, render is low quality too, you should try using the sharpen filter in gimp when your render has lost quality due to scaling imo. and the c4d's clash, dunno why u didnt just make em face the same way xd