You need to realize people on da internetz are a bit more sensitive then you may expect. I know you didn't mean to sound like an ass, but you did.
You pointed out several things in a way that upset Max already.
When you said:
Any player with a bit of knowledge of how to sector will systematically pick off the enemies 1 by 1 by luring them 1 at a time and carefully killing them. That is going to take a long time depending on the level and the players level. Keep in mind the other players will have to wait for their turn so it will get lengthy and many players will leave because theyre tired of waiting. Or what if a player just just wants to troll you and runs around not hitting the enemies? Is he disqualified? What if he occasionally hits the enemies? Where do you draw the line?
I think you need to make a lot more rules for this or it will be too hard to manage or it will just get out of control. If you plan on doing this with friends then thats cool but if you're doing this with randoms then goodluck its going to be tough.
it made it seem like you purposely shit on his event.
When you put a lot of effort in pointing out a little problem it seems like you're trying to piss him off. I know you don't mean it that way, but as long as he feels offended, it'll cause drama. You could've said:
"Time may be an issue. If you don't tweak the rules of the event you'll end up with low levels taking a long time to finish the event."
"I think you'll have a hard time doing this with people that you don't know until you change the rules"
All I did was take out pointless questions. You don't need to ask a bunch of questions in your post, I think max is smart enough to understand why doing such a thing would improve his event.
Also, you have to understand, this is HIS event. He may just be doing it for fun, maybe he doesn't want to have "good" events like yours. A event being unbalanced is perfectly fine if it's just for fun. Also, let's be honest here, you aren't upset about him calling you an idiot. You don't need to admit it because you still want him to get a punishment, but I know you aren't that sensitive.
Note: This isn't meant to cause drama of any sort and if cooky wants me to remove this post / lock it, I will.