[Nucleaon]

Why not make it so that if a player quits, the gp stays. I just went from 800k gp to 600k because some guy quit to join Telepathy. Pisses me off.

[mhj]

+1. Redemption would never had lost that much GP, would still be dead thought. I already suggested it long ago.

[zepher2211]

I have had kenny transfer gp from multiple people who were going to quit, or were breaking guild rules, etc.

[mhj]

I have had kenny transfer gp from multiple people who were going to quit, or were breaking guild rules, etc.

But he can't do that everytime.

[zepher2211]

That's part of what I wanted to do when I suggested a guild cp

[Zack66775]

+1. Points were gained so they should stay for that guild.... SORRY NUCLEON!

[asmit10]

It's called GUILD POINTS. If a person leaves the guild, you lose a part of the guild, therefor you lose part of your guild points. If GP stayed with a person that'd be retarted. The player earned his guild points with A guild, therefor his GP should stay with the guild, not the player. If the player leaves then his work was done for nothing which means you lose the GP.

Both suggestions listed in this thread = fail, imo.

[asmit10]

It's called GUILD POINTS. If a person leaves the guild, you lose a part of the guild, therefor you lose part of your guild points. If GP stayed with a person that'd be retarted. The player earned his guild points with A guild, therefor his GP should stay with the guild, not the player. If the player leaves then his work was done for nothing which means you lose the GP.

Both suggestions listed in this thread = fail, imo.

He earned his points by himself. the points should stay with him. all that hard work that the person would put into earning those points to be lost when you leave your guild for a better or new one would be pointless. It should go to what ever new guild he is in.

He earned the points for the guild that he was in. Not for him.

[Zack66775]

Very true but still

[Yz]

It's their GP, and as a member their GP makes up a part of the guilds GP. I've always considered this idea but it's just not the fair thing to do or I'd be hopping to every guild in the game and getting them 1mil G P and then leaving, it'd be illegitimate for them basically if it was all mine then I wasn't even a part of their guild anymore.

[Zack66775]

It's their GP, and as a member their GP makes up a part of the guilds GP. I've always considered this idea but it's just not the fair thing to do or I'd be hopping to every guild in the game and getting them 1mil G P and then leaving, it'd be illegitimate for them basically if it was all mine then I wasn't even a part of their guild anymore.

Still true

[Yz]

Wow my grammar failed hard there. But yeah you get the point. It's my GP and theirs, not theirs only

[Click]

GP should stay in the guild, because its for the guild and is named GUILD points....

[Yz]

GP should stay in the guild, because its for the guild and is named GUILD points....

Fail argument, get an education before you contribute.

[zepher2211]

GP should stay in the guild, because its for the guild and is named GUILD points....

Fail argument, get an education before you contribute.

Your argument fails too, you used an example where aparently all guilds accept guild hoppers. o-o"