[zepher2211]

I don't see what makes #3 "real typography"

Because it is the only typography work, you didn't ask whether it was a sig, you asked why it's typography, which is obvious, point out one other entry that actually used text to design something o-o

[Nucleaon]

7 12 13

[NoS]

I don't see what makes #3 "real typography"

Because it is the only typography work, you didn't ask whether it was a sig, you asked why it's typography, which is obvious, point out one other entry that actually used text to design something o-o

I don't see what makes it any more 'real' than the rest is the difference

going by your implied logic that would make doc 'Ouse the most 'real typography'

[iwasbobo]

I'm certain #7 isn't a typography. Even if there are a few words on the render, it's a rendered (though modified) person.

I'll have to agree, but I wasn't around during this so I was unable to talk with the other judges. House is the focal in this one, not the text. =/