I'd like to post about this since I don't want you guys to quit the server over what happened.
PvP was disabled when Sockie died. She died from a zombie, it even said it in the chat, and then Eco999 picked up sockie's items. Sockie then started to complain about how eco killed her, when he didn't.
I decided that i'd turn PvP on to give you guys a chance to get the items back, because Eco got them fairly. Your whole group then died from him, and I disabled pvp again.
Eco then smashed a chest while pvp was off, which was my fault for not announcing that pvp was going off, as you pointed out in-game. I then tp'd to eco999, used /kill eco999, and saw his items drop onto the ground.
A few minutes later Sockie said that eco still had some of your items, so I used /invsee and saw that he had 60 iron and some melons, I took them and gave them to Sockie.
If anything Eco got screwed over and I shouldn't have even helped. If you have any problems with what happened, then please point them out.