Here's a solution that I'd propose:
Rage admits to nothing, and I really don't know if she is lying or not, but we can't prove that she not. BUT since she seems to have a mysterious ability to get scammed items/accs back from this scammer, I suggest we let her give back the items/accs to everyone that asks for it (as long as they were scammed by that IP). If she succeeds, one way or another, give her 2 week to 30 day ban. If not....locked forevah. I think most ppl would prefer to have their stuff back than see a scammer get banned...,